No Bond, No Stay: A California Court Lets a $3.28 Million Judgment Be Enforced During Appeal
An appeal does not automatically pause collection in California, and a recent ruling shows how hard it is to get that pause for free. On November 10, 2026, a California court denied Laurie Siegenthaler's renewed request to stay enforcement, without a bond, of a $3,283,850.53 judgment in favour of Ginamarie Andreoli. The judgment, entered on December 8, 2025, in the Estate of Alfred Andreoli probate matter, has been on appeal since December 12, 2025, and the appellate court had already denied a writ of supersedeas in January.
The court's reasoning followed the statute. Under Probate Code section 1301(e), an appeal from a money judgment does not stay its operation unless a bond is posted as provided in Code of Civil Procedure section 917.1. The narrower Probate Code section 1310(b) route, meant for exceptional cases where injury or loss is clear, was not made out. A request to waive the bond for indigency under section 995.240 also failed: the court found the initial showing insufficient, the supplemental evidence late, and, even considering it, other factors weighed against waiver, including the estate's private character, its pendency since December 2018, and the history of the case.
For judgment holders and buyers, the point is practical and valuable: in California, a money judgment remains enforceable during appeal unless the debtor posts security, so an appeal, by itself, is not a reason to discount a judgment's present value.
