Out-of-Court Defaults Now Dominate, and Their Recoveries Are Slipping
November 2026
Most distressed debt no longer defaults in a courtroom. Distressed debt exchanges have made up a record 79% of defaults so far this year in CLO portfolios rated by Fitch Ratings, exceeding the previous high of 69% set in 2024, according to Asset Securitization Report. September continued the pattern, with five of six obligor default events taking the form of exchanges rather than a Chapter 11 filing.
The reason creditors have tolerated that shift is also weakening. Exchanges have historically delivered higher recoveries than in-court bankruptcies, but Fitch found par-weighted nominal recoveries for distressed exchanges fell to 85.0% in 2025 from 93.0% in 2024. For lenders caught in below-par exchanges, including liability-management transactions where lenders outside the favoured group receive debt priced below par, recoveries fell much further, to 65.5% in 2025 from 86.0% the year before. Weighted-average recoveries across the dataset ranged from 75.8% to 92.7%, depending on the valuation method.
For holders and buyers of distressed positions, the practical point is that "out of court" no longer means "better outcome" by default. Which side of an exchange a holder sits on, inside the favoured group or outside it, is increasingly what decides the recovery, and that position needs pricing before the exchange is announced, not after.
Sources: Asset Securitization Report
